Interesting case fore international smallcap
Analysis of Article on Investment Opportunities in International and Emerging Small Cap Stocks
1. advice, warnings, and key indicators for private investors:
-
Opportunity: Diversification beyond U.S. large-cap stocks. Given high concentration and valuations in large U.S. companies, along with uncertainty surrounding "U.S. exceptionalism" due to recent policy changes (tariffs), investors should consider diversifying geographically and by market capitalization. [Introduction]
-
Potential: International and emerging small-cap markets offer attractive expected returns. AQR's Capital Market Assumptions for the next 5-10 years indicate that small-cap stocks in international developed markets (Intl. Dev'd Small Cap) and emerging markets (Emg. Market Small Cap) have higher expected real returns (5.4% and 5.6% respectively) than U.S. large caps (4.2%) and U.S. small caps (4.4%). [Exhibit 2, The Beta Opportunity]
-
Indicator: Expected EPS (earnings per share) growth. Small-cap companies in both emerging and international markets have higher forecasted EPS growth than their large-cap counterparts. Particularly, small-cap stocks in emerging markets may be poised for faster growth. [The Beta Opportunity]
-
Advantage: Better diversification properties. International and emerging small-cap markets have historically shown lower correlation with U.S. large-cap stocks compared to international and emerging large-cap stocks. This provides better portfolio diversification. [Exhibit 3, The Beta Opportunity]
-
Indicator: Percentage of revenue from domestic sales. Small-cap companies outside the U.S. often derive a larger portion of their revenue from domestic customers. This makes them potentially less vulnerable to disruptions from recent tariff policies. [Exhibit 4, The Beta Opportunity]
-
Opportunity: Greater potential for alpha (excess returns) in the small-cap segment. The extensive scope and large number of companies within the small-cap universe present a notable advantage for investment managers with the resources and expertise to effectively explore these segments. The sheer volume of small-cap stocks often exceeds the analytical capabilities of sell-side analysts, leading to many small-cap stocks remaining under-analyzed or overlooked. This gap may offer investors opportunities to identify and benefit from relatively untapped alpha. [Exhibit 5, The Alpha Opportunity]
-
Strategy: A systematic (quantitative) investment approach may be well-suited for small caps. Systematic managers have historically shown an ability to add consistent alpha over their benchmarks in these regions. By identifying and capitalizing on market opportunities that may be overlooked by discretionary managers and maintaining more diversified portfolios that help reduce idiosyncratic risk, they have the ability to achieve higher active returns. [Exhibit 6, The Alpha Opportunity]
-
Warning: Higher transaction costs in small-cap markets. While these inefficiencies may offer skilled investors meaningful opportunities to uncover mispricing and generate alpha, they also tend to be accompanied by higher transaction costs, which can erode returns and contribute to the persistence of inefficiencies by discouraging broader market participation. [The Alpha Opportunity]
-
Risk: Elevated valuations in U.S. large caps. Historical cyclically-adjusted price-to-earnings (CAPE) ratios show that U.S. large caps (Russell 1000) are trading at relatively high levels compared to both their own history and other market segments. [Exhibit 1]
-
Principle: Market leadership is cyclical. Although U.S. stocks have led for about 15 years, it is important to remember that market leadership has historically been cyclical, not a permanent feature. [The Beta Opportunity]
2. Main themes in the discussion:
The article argues that investors should consider increasing their exposure to small-cap stocks, particularly in international developed and emerging markets. This is justified by several factors in a market environment characterized by high concentration and valuation in U.S. large-cap stocks, as well as increasing uncertainty about America's continued exceptional market performance.
The Beta Opportunity: The authors point out that AQR's long-term (5-10 years) capital market assumptions indicate higher expected real returns for international and emerging small-cap stocks compared to U.S. large caps [The Beta Opportunity]. Furthermore, these small-cap companies often have higher forecasted earnings growth (EPS growth). An important advantage is also diversification; international and emerging small-cap stocks have historically had lower correlation with U.S. large caps [Exhibit 3]. This can be partly explained by them deriving a larger share of their revenue from their domestic markets, making them less vulnerable to global trade policy and tariffs [Exhibit 4].
The Alpha Opportunity: The large and often under-analyzed universe of international and emerging small-cap stocks provides fertile ground for active managers to generate excess returns (alpha) [The Alpha Opportunity]. Lower analyst coverage means fundamental information is priced in more slowly, creating opportunities to identify mispricing [Exhibit 5]. The article highlights that systematic (quantitative) investment strategies may be particularly well-suited to exploit these opportunities, given the potentially higher transaction costs in the segment [Exhibit 6].
Conclusion: Despite the strong performance of U.S. large caps in recent years, the authors warn against the risk of today's lower expected future returns and increased volatility. They encourage investors to look beyond the most familiar markets and consider the potential benefits—higher expected returns, diversification, and alpha opportunities—that may lie in international and emerging small-cap stocks.